From productive interactions to productive science system dynamics: understanding the key dimensions in developing SSH research societal impact

17/10/2018 to 19/10/2018
T2S Technology Transfer Society annual conference 2018
In this paper we seek to realise the potential that Spaapen & Van Drooge’s productive interactions concept offers, but which we argue has been lost through its operationalisation as a process of ‘counting interactions’. Productive interactions arise through moments of contact between two very different systems (the societal and the scientific), and each system values societal impact in very different ways. Finding mutual value in that interaction is important, and we argue that value in both arises when network arrangements shift, as academic disciplines solve urgent scientific problems and as societies address negative living conditions. Productive interactions approach assumes the value-frameworks of the wider networks within which particular knowledge sets become actionable. However, our constructive critique highlights the omission of the wider elements of science and social systems within which productive interactions takes place (and whose dynamics ultimately determine the final scientific and societal impact of that research). Indeed, research evaluation to date has not considered the consequences of the productive interactions in terms of these changing relationships. To contribute to this lacunae, we propose a model that conceptualises a meso-level system comprising interactions between actors within two subsystems and we apply it to diverse examples of examples of productive interactions in the field of social science and humanities gathered in the framework of a European project.
Benneworth, P., Olmos-Peñuela, J., Muhonen, R., Castro-Martínez, E.